Cloud Atlas: A Novel by David Mitchell Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $9.04 You Save: $5.96 (40%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $4.72 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of Cloud Atlas: A Novel
Book Review: "Souls cross ages like clouds cross skies"
Summary: 4 Stars
Whether you preferred number9dream or Ghostwritten, Cloud Atlas is the best of both worlds as Mitchell's most ambitious and polished work to date. Instead of the loosely related, chronolocigally concurrent stories of Ghostwritten, Cloud Atlas uses stories that are temporally dispersed, instead of just geographically so, and for the most part Mitchell manages to avoid the biggest fault of Ghostwritten, the stories all have a powerful and recognizable impact on their flanking stories without seeming so contrived it takes away from the story. The story of an American Notary crossing the Pacific in the 1860's has an impact on the story (not just plot-wise, but thematically was well) of a Belgian composer in the 1930's which effects the story of the 1975 story of a Californian investigative journalist who recurs in the next story of an elderly editor in conteporary London who has an influence on the story of a Korean genetically engineered slave in the near future who in turn figues prominently in the central, post-apocalyptic world of young Hawaiian tribesman. (How's that for a run-on?) However, let me sneak in a word on the novel's structure: unline Ghostwritten, in which each story was told in its entirety at once, each story in Cloud Atlas is divided right down the middle into two halves. The first half of each story is told in ascending chronological order. Then, when we get to the post-apocalyptic story, it is told in its entirety before the other five stories finish themselves up in reverse chronological order. Hence, we start in the 1860's, and we end in the 1860's. Each story is nested inside the chronologically earlier ones, and each contain the chronologically later ones inside. This structure is in no way a mere gimmick. Mitchell uses it to produce quite an effect.
During the chronologically progressive first half of the stories, Michell begins to unfold for the reader that what is happening in each story is contributing, seemingly inexoriably, to the bleak future of mankind. Mitchell seems to say that, given the prevalent greed in human nature, that's where we're going to end up, no matter what. Hence, he sets up the theme that figures so prominently in the end of Ghostwritten: the role of human agency in the face of the seemingly contradictory facts of human nature. However, nothing in any of Mitchell's novels is quite that simple. As the stories begin to unwind, we begin to see the role choice has played in all this, and we see the hope for mankind's future that each story's second half produces after the seeming condemnation of the first half of the book. We get to see the impact each character's life has on the lives of the other characters. It's something of a surreal experience to read.
Now, I also said that Cloud Atlas Also includes the best parts of number9dream. While the overall structure and driving force of the novel is descended from Ghostwritten, the novel's lighter, more playful side descends from number9dream. Like Mitchell's second novel, Cloud Atlas is very playful as far as what is real and what isn't. Again, it's up to the reader to decide what to believe and how exactly each episode relates to those other episodes surrounding it, and then what kind of impact that level of reality in that story has on the novel as a whole. It also incorporates the exciting aura of Mitchells narration and language found in number9dream along with philosophical moments that are out of place in the real world, but fit right into the context of Mitchell's novel as such passages often do into the works of Don Delillo. We also get the depth of character in at least four out of these six stories that we get with Eji in number9dream that Ghostwritten didn't have time for. These characters have history, emotion, vulnerability, and the ability to adapt and change.
Is this the greatest novel ever? No. As you can see, I give it four stars. It's amazing, and I wouldn't be saddened to see it get nominated for (or win) the next Booker, but Mitchell has not yet written his masterpiece. Often, he still comes across as heavy-handed, especially in his criticism of colonialism (massive running theme) and human nature. (For him, they are rather blurred together--something he tends to do much more often than many other British Post-Colonialist writers.) Also, occasionally he telegraphs a plot twist, gives us a not-quite-satisfying climax, or wraps up a story a little too quickly. These faults are most evident in the sixth story, but they occasionally become evident in almost every story to some extent with the notable exception of the story of the Belgian composer (this is the story that really ties the whole novel together, and is probably the single best thing Mitchell has ever written).
But overall, I highly recommend this book to previous Mitchell fans-it's definately his most well-rounded book-and I would also recommend this to fans of authors such as Jeanette Winterson, Don Delillo, Salman Rushdie, and others of their ilk. If you didn't much care for either of Mitchell's books, I don't really think this one will change your opinion.
Book Review: 'Disappointment is an understatement'
Summary: 1 Stars
'Disapointment'is an understatement for this book which is, in my 44 years of reading, possibly the most awful thing I've read. The idea is, in theory, brilliant, but despite my plodding, persisting and struggling through the pages, I found nothing to suggest it was anything other than - dare I say, amateur. It didn't hang together, it made absolutely no sense and the plots were just fantastical and unrealistic. I won't deny Mitchell's undeniable talent as a critically acclaimed and esteemed author, it's just this book......One of the reviews I read on this site was from someone who had read it and wanted to claim their life back for the hours wasted on reading it. I share this sentiment, having chosen it as the only fiction to bring on my Spanish holiday. Sadly, I feel completely ripped off, conned even. I'd have got more sense from actually sticking my head in the clouds for a few days, and wish I had.Book Review: A Brilliant Work
Summary: 5 Stars
I read this book about 5 years ago when it was hot off the press, and am always telling friends to read it. It's such an ingenious work of fiction. I had so much pleasure reading this book. The writing is fantastic, like 5 writers in one book, all great, and all the same writer. Savory, page-turning, and super-intelligent. Awesome to the very last sentence.Book Review: A Common Thread
Summary: 4 Stars
Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell was an exticing read. It grabbed you and didn't let go. I felt the need to keep reading to find the common thread and once I understood the "Sextet" it made the parts all become whole. It is a book that will stay with you for years to come.Book Review: A Literary Palindrome
Summary: 5 Stars
David Mitchell was interviewed by the great Margaret Throsby on Sydney radio when he came to town in February, 2005. She said the novel was like a palindrome in that you could read the chapters backwards. This very unusual literary device is used by the writer to stunning effect. Indeed, I was not too keen on some of the stories in the first half but loved them in the second. This is where the use of connection and coincidence come into play. Though their styles are different Mitchell reminds me of the early Paul Auster in his fascination with chance and fate.
I recommend this book highly but I think to really enjoy it you should read Mitchell's debut novel, Ghostwritten, first and don't skip it's epigraph - a quote from Thornton Wilder. A lot of clues to the puzzle that is Cloud Atlas are contained therein. Cloud Atlas can be read again and again to pick up the synchronicity which may affect all our lives. And it is a great and intriguing read.