Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
(Click here)
Book Reviews of Darkly Dreaming Dexter
Book Review: Why the criticism?
Summary: 5 Stars
I, like many others reviewing this book, have watched the show first and then was so impressed with it, felt compelled to read the book. I haven't felt this eager to read a book in a long time and I wasn't disappointed. What I am disappointed with is the largely negative reviews here.
Everyone's entitled to their opinions but I felt some of them must have been reading a different book to myself. Ok, I will admit that the book is not as big as I was expecting but then I don't feel it needed to be. The book is full of humour and the characters are interesting.
Some characters, such as Angel Batista, are not seen as much in the book as they are in tv show, but other characters such as Vince Masuoka are seen more. The producers of the show decided to show more of Batista than Masuoka and that is their perogative. I thought the characterisation of Masouka was good and showed that perhaps Dexter could have a friend, or at least someone to connect with.
Perhaps the criticism that has puzzled me the most is the theory that the character of Dexter is not likeable enough in the book. Correct me if I'm wrong, but considering the self-mocking tone displayed in the book as written from Dexter's perspective, it left me feeling like that was the point: Dexter knows what he is, and what he is isn't suppoosed to be likeable.
His constant references to not being human make him an anti-hero, not someone to be admired and revered for being righteous. If people choose to like Dexter (which they admittedly do and I am one of them), it's because we choose to, not because we're supposed to.
True, as it is written from Dexter's point of view, there is the sense that we are supposed to sympathise with Dexter but, after all, he is still a serial killer, and is in his own admission, a man with no guilt response.
The story is a lot shorter than the tv show but then a tv show's job is take something like Dexter and add their own spin on it: it's the same with Hollywood movies; I urge anyone to read Stephen King's The Shining and then see Stanley Kubrick's version and tell me just how different it is.
The obvious difference is the character of LaGuerta. In the show, she is a stronger, more competent character, however in the book she is shown as someone not particularly intelligent but displaying a hard edge at points. The main difference regarding LaGuerta is something I won't go into for fear of ruining the book for those who haven't read it.
The book has a lot of quirky humour and the story, although short, is still very interesting and inventive. Some characters have more depth than others and some are very different from the tv show. What I will say, to finish, is this: if you've seen the tv show first, please be aware it is quite different to the tv show but that shouldn't become a criticism of the book.
Television producers jobs are to take a book or script and tailor it to their own needs: they are two completely different mediums and one shouldn't be criticised because of the other.
Book Review: Better than the series, but only just
Summary: 5 Stars
After I saw the series on FX and then found out there was a book I thought, as i usually do that I wouldn't bother, due to me picturing everything I saw in the series, in the book.
However with this book at appeared so much different in parts and is well worth a read. I can't wait to read the next two books, i just wish i had read them when they came out as i am a very impatient person.
Book Review: Doughnuts anyone
Summary: 3 Stars
It is in the first person perspective we meet and get to know Dexter. He sees things quite differently from the ordinary man. Because he is extraordinary, a cold hearted cold blooded killer, with a sense of comedic reflection as he experiences life.
Lindsay's prose reminds me of "One flew over the Cuckoo's Nest" by the descriptive narrative. There are some pages I had to read over 2 or 3 times because they sounded so good. Just find out, read the first page and you'll know what I mean.
It is a black psychotic book with a rye smile and sitting on the edge of your seat pace as you ask yourself 'what will happen next?' I would recomend this to anyone. It's a good read.
Book Review: Wonderfully Weird Wording
Summary: 5 Stars
I love the style and the language used in this book. If I hadn't seen the TV series first I would have been disappointed in the way the book was adapted for the screen.
The tension created by the storyline made me want to read the book from cover to cover without putting it down. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys a well-written, humorous mystery.
Book Review: Dearly Different Dexter
Summary: 4 Stars
I had read this twice before seeing it on TV and decided after seeing the TV series to read it again. Yes, I enjoyed reading this interesting story with a serial killer with somewhat of a conscience as it's core character (have to dance around that Hero word, he really isn't). The conscience he has is the memory of his now-dead father who was a cop, a man who had seen too much of the mean streets and believed that sometimes there was a good reason to kill some people and that the law didn't always catch and find the evil roaming the streets. Instead of trying to stop Dexter's urges he encourages him to find "legitimate" targets, prey on the serial killers.
The weak parts of the story were when he would appear to be getting psychic impressions from the other killer, when you were supposed to be wondering if it could be possibly himself, a plotline that was thankfully dropped in the series as it was weak. It just didn't really work for me (and from reading other reviews it didn't work for other people either). I did enjoy the story, it's different enough from the series to be an interesting independent read but in some ways the TV series got a lot of the good points without stressing on the bad points.
A book I've recommended to others and got some mixed reviews, everything from loathing to love.