Lirael: Daughter of the Clayr
by Garth Nix

List Price: $7.99
Our Price: $1.77
You Save: $6.22 (78%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy Used: from $0.01 (click here)
Category: Book
See more book details and other editions

Book Summary Information

Book Reviews of Lirael: Daughter of the Clayr

Book Review: "Things Long Dormant are Stirring, or Being Woken..."
Summary: 5 Stars

But of course, fate has other ideas for these two - evil is once more abroad in the Old Kingdom. A terrible necromancer named Hedge is causing trouble in the West, beginning the first steps of a plan that threatens both the Clayr and the Royal Family - not to mention the Old Kingdom and Ancelstierre, the non-magical country across the Wall. When Lirael unleashes and brings to life a mysterious magical dog known as the Disreputable Dog, and Sameth runs away from home in order to find his ignorant Ancelstierrean friend Nick who crosses the Wall, the two are thrown into the path of Hedge and so destined to stop his evil. And there is yet more going on, a secret bond between Sameth and Lirael that they are unaware of, but need to discover if they are to understand what is truly expected of them.

Once more Garth Nix has written an amazing book: a rich, mysterious fantasy world, an intriguing, twisting plot, strong and realistic characterisation... Nix really is a master at all of these areas. The Old Kingdom has been added upon, especially in regards to the Clayr, who were just distant allies in "Sabriel". Now we get to see deep inside their home and customs, including the huge library that is surely every book-lovers dream: not just a place of endless levels of manuscripts but even deeper chambers of monsters, magic, artifacts, underground gardens, buriel chambers...I could have wandered in there with Lirael forever.

Lirael and Sameth are very different from Sabriel as protagonists: where Sabriel was confident, strong and focused, Sameth and Lirael are more hesitant about their chosen paths. In doing so, Nix has made them more realistic, but readers may miss the Nancy Drew-like qualities of Sabriel that made her such a popular heroine. I must say I had quite a soft spot for Sameth - unfortunatly some readers have dismissed him as a bit of a wimp, but I completely understood his fear over the huge responsibility that was placed over him, and as another reviewer pointed out, he is one of the few fantasy characters that is not just reluctant about his duties, but downright terrified of them! Either way, I found his fear easier to grasp than Lirael's suicidal decision to chuck herself off the Clayr glacier.

The Disreputable Dog and Mogget are the highlights of the story: their meeting was exactly what I expected it to be (throw a cat and a dog together in a boat and watch the fireworks!) and provide most of the comic relief in the story, whilst dropping a few clues that there is more to their identity than meets the eye. Mogget (my favourite) is introduced a little later than I would have liked, but is still the bad tempered, superior white cat that we all remember from "Sabriel".

Of course Touchstone and Sabriel aren't forgotten, and I thought it was a nice touch that their eldest daughter Ellimere was named after one of Sabriel's school friends that died at the end of the first book. However, I did catch one continuity error - in "Sabriel" Mogget called Sabriel's father 'Emeritus', but here he is named as 'Terciel'. Given that "Lirael" was written six years after "Sabriel" was published, its hardly surprising that this tiny detail was missed, but still...

Basically, "Lirael" is one of the best, most original fantasy books you can read, certainly up there with the likes of Rowling, Tolkien, Pullman and Lewis in terms of readablity and popularity. Be sure to read "Sabriel" first, and you'll definitely be reading for its sequel in a hurry.

Action & Adventure Books

• Books > Subjects > Literature & Fiction > Genre Fiction
• Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy > Epic
• Teens > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy