Making Money (Discworld) by Terry Pratchett Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $8.63 You Save: $17.32 (67%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $2.85 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of Making Money (Discworld)
Book Review: Great Fun As Always, But Not His Best
Summary: 4 Stars
A bad Terry Pratchett book would be great (and have been in the past) and although this isn't earth shatteringly fantastic, it is still very well worth a read. Personally I like Moist Von Lipwigs character and his interaction with Lord Vetinari is top class. I think Pratchett should give him a rest for a while after 'Raising Taxes' is complete, at least to let the poor guy have a rest. I think my biggest complaint about this book, is that Terry (or his publishers) tried to squeeze a BIG story into a much shorter book. I felt that it needed filling out and certain characters came across as a little 2D.
Book Review: Standard Discworld fare
Summary: 4 Stars
After more than thirty books in the Discworld series, readers know what to expect. Pratchett is admirably consistent - true, he does produce the odd weak novel, but on the whole most are pretty good. 'Making Money' is standard Discworld fare, a good read though not outstandingly so. It's enjoyable and should please most Discworld followers. Readers new to Discworld would definitely be better off starting with one of the earlier stories, although this could be read in isolation, some of the 'in' jokes will be lost on Pratchett newcomers.
The unfortunately named hero, Moist von Lipwig, was first introduced in the previous-but-one (adult) Discworld offering, 'Going Postal.' He's an engaging enough character and still has room for development, unlike some of the Discworld's more heavily used characters (e.g. Vimes).
In 'Making Money' Moist is seconded from his successful role as Postmaster General to sort out Ankh-Morpork's troubled Royal Mint and bank. Whilst Moist attempts to modernise the bank in face of stiff resistance from the stuffy traditionalists of the banking world, his fiancee is busy digging something mysterious out of a distant field... These seemingly unrelated story threads soon come together in a typically Discworldian conclusion.
The supporting cast features many old familiars - the Patrician has a large role, which is welcome, and there are cameo appearances from several of the star watchmen (Vimes, Carrot, Detritus, Colon and Nobby) and from journalist Sacharissa Cripslock. One disappointment is the near-absence of Death (the character), who gets only one very brief scene. There are also plenty of new characters, though none of these are particularly mould breaking.
Overall, it's an enjoyable read, well paced and with decent humour. Like 'Going Postal', it is unusual for a Discworld book in being divided into chapters, which I think makes for easier reading. There aren't really any surprises, but then why change a winning formula? If you like Discworld, you will like this, if you don't, then you won't. A safe bet, even if it isn't the outstanding read of the year.
Book Review: Not his best, but it's up there with them
Summary: 4 Stars
It's always difficult when introducing a new character. I feel that Pterry loves Moist perhaps more than a lot of us do, and he's almost trying too hard to make us love him too. I like Moist, I do - but he's no Vimes.
I am not sure that I really quite GOT this one, it kind of seemed two books shunted together, I'm probably missing the point about the gold and the golems or something.
But the character who makes this book live is Vetinari. For the first time (other than a brief glimpse in Night Watch) we see Vetinari as he really works behind the scenes to achieve the city's survival. I devoured every speech of his and was just thrilled to bits to see him out of the shadows. Perhaps it is because Moist would be a great Patrician and Vetinari is grooming him for such? Who can say?
More Vimes please, Pterry.
Book Review: Vetinari volunteers von Lipwig
Summary: 5 Stars
In "Going Postal", Pratchett introduced Moist von Lipwig, a condemned confidence trickster, at his "end", hanged at the order of Ankh-Morpork's Patrician, Havelock Vetinari. It wasn't Moist who was executed, however, but Albert Spangler, his most frequently used alias. That identity was swept away to enable Lord Vetinari's wish to rejuvenate the City's postal system. Moist was up to the task, transforming an ancient, creaking and nearly obsolete civil service into a humming success. The rejuvenation kept the post office a City institution instead of divested into greedy, private hands.
But success isn't Moist's desired state. He craves danger, illicit activity, deception and the thrill of the chase. To keep his hand in, he must break into his own post office! Vetinari didn't spare Moist on a whim. He knows his man and his methods, deftly manoeuvring the talented thief for his own ends. "Tyrant" or no, Vetinari lives for the City of Ankh-Morpork, using whatever means available to keep it going effectively. With no other vested interest and lacking anything like an army for enforcing his aims, Vetinari relies on guile and one of the most devious personalities in literature. He uses that talent to manoeuvre Moist's taking over the Royal Bank and Mint. Moist will be "making money" in a new way.
"Ankh-Morpork" of course, won't be found in any Rand McNally [in case you were thinking of looking]. That's because Vetinari's City is the largest on the Discworld. Pratchett has produced over three dozen books on this world, which is only partly imaginary. His slogan for the series: "Discworld is a world, and a mirror of worlds" reveals the reflection there is us. There are a few exotic characters residing on the Discworld. The City Watch hires trolls, dwarves and even promoted a werewolf to Sergeant, for example. These are minor characters here, although golems move to near-centre stage in this tale. One of them, who's discovered "ladies' magazines" and books on deportment, has donned a blue dress and dubbed herself "Gladys". She is Moist's personal maid, demurely turning her back when he dresses.
Golems are seen as a threat by many in Ankh-Morpork. They do the repetitive, mindless tasks without murmur or complaint. If they cause job loss with such behaviour, however, the economy will suffer - as will the Bank. Run by the Chief Cashier, Malvolio Bent, who staunchly defends traditional standards, innovation has little place in the Bank. A nephew of the former Chairman has introduced speculative forecasting on the City's economy, including what might transpire in conditions of mass unemployment. Scorning anything as crude as an abacus, Hubert has expanded on the ancient water clock to create The Glooper, a maze of glass pipes, valves and buckets to trace the impact of small changes in the flow of money. Hubert calls it his "analogy machine". Silicon being the basis for glass and computers is a point to remember.
Hubert is a Lavish, the family that has run and controlled the Royal Bank for generations. The Lavishes, are, well, lavish. They are Old Money, which means they know how to save, spend, and use it for their own ambitions. One Lavish, Cosmo, has even more grandiose plans - take over the management of the Bank, and depose Vetinari in the process. Moist, as the new Master of the Royal Mint, and keeper of the present Chairman, a multi-breed dog named Mr Fusspot, stands in Cosmo's path. Moist seems immune from Cosmo's machinations, until a figure from the past arrives. Cribbins knows Albert Spangler from old and intends to benefit from the knowledge. Only Vetinari is aware of who Moist actually is, keeping that secret for his own purposes. Now, Moist's past is rising up like a restless shade. How will Ankh-Morpork respond when it learns their admired Postmaster and Master of the Royal Mint is a former crook? Especially when it's discovered that the gold reserve keeping the economy ticking over and backing up Moist's innovation of paper money has mysteriously disappeared?
To those who've read Pratchett, extolling his style and wit will be redundant. He's a master at word bending, double meaning and adapting. The Bank's cellar, a huge vault, was excavated by a former Chairman on speculation that it would attract a beneficent god. "If we build it, wilt thou comest?" is a typical Pratchett tossed-off line. Yet, as any fan will testify, he's not limited to petty wit. He understands issues confronting us all, conveying them with panache. He does this through his characters, at whose creation Pratchett is a master. Moist is one of his finer efforts, but his on-going depiction of Vetinari through the Discworld series has made him a favoured character: "Do I need to wear a badge that says tyrant?" Pratchett's characterisations, and the twists and arabesques of his plots, spiced with an accomplished knowledge of his topic, keeps his books not only on the "Must Read" list, but rewards those who pick them up again and again. [stephen a. haines - Ottawa, Canada]
Book Review: Rincewind and repeat
Summary: 1 Stars
The title of this book MUST be an admission that the discworld series should be put to sleep now. Is the next book to be titled 'For old rope'?