Odd Hours by Dean Koontz Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $1.49 You Save: $25.51 (94%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $0.01 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of Odd Hours
Book Review: Disappointing Change of Course in Odd Series
Summary: 2 Stars
As a fan of the Odd Series, we felt this recent installment skewed far from what made the other books so good. Odd Thomas has lost the innocence and wonder that made him likable. Instead of encountering everyday ghosts and isolated catastrophes, he is now battling world-wide destruction. The encounters seemed overboard and silly. Dodging bullets. Killing sprees. This is not Odd.
Plus the whole 'mysterious' girl who refuses to answer any inquires is simply annoying and frustrating. He must be priming her for a future book, but here it was a waste with no closure. At least tease us with some purpose or indirect bites.
Hopefully, this is not the path Odd Thomas will continue on. Hopefully, Odd can return to his roots and make the story interesting again.
Book Review: Disappointing installment, but a very interesting social phenomena
Summary: 3 Stars
I'm writing this review in the hope that it will add something to the commentary here. I will admit to having anticipated the release of this book with much interest. When the day arrived (May 20, 2008) when it was offered for sale I bought a copy. Over the ten days since, I have noted that this fourth book is being promoted in a much broader way than the previous books. I've seen "Odd Hours" offered for sale at almost every retailer I've visited (including two grocery stores), I've received a few e-mails from book vendors that promoted this book above all else that became available that week, I've seen a video production starring "Odd" and promoting his new story run continuously on the TV sets at the Target store, and I've watched a local "newscast" that covered the release of the book in local stores. Wow! That Dean guy has some savvy marketing folks on his side...and he has created a break-out character in the genre that has somehow "spoken to" a legion of fans. This is quite an accomplishment for any writer, even for one of the best-selling authors of the recent decade. So, I guess you could say that I'm interested in both the "Odd Phenomena" as I call it and in the books themselves. I'm a professional writer (not of fiction) so I have enjoyed Mr. Koontz's "Odd" books on another level: I have read them as good genre fiction and as very good examples of an author having created a very sellable character based on an established formula and writing style.
That said, I will confess that I have enjoyed each one of the four "Odd Thomas" books. However, this fourth installment (ironically the most hyped) was, sadly, the weakest, at least in my estimation. To explain that last remark, I would like to comment on each of the earlier installments first.
The original "Odd Thomas" book was a stellar achievement. Here we have a great premise that is very interestingly spun into a heroic character for our times (even though the "I see dead people" talent is not an original concept of Koontz's). When "Odd" speaks, of course, it is Mr. Koontz that is doing the speaking and I've learned a great deal through the four installments about this author's philosophy of good and evil, the choices that we make, and the root meaning of our lives. Along the way, we get a great story filled with many memorable characters that are fully fleshed out and who get to interact in exciting and emotionally affecting situations. I was stunned, really, by how good the first novel is...it really is such a great achievement that almost anything that came after it would be anticlimactic, at least in some way. My rating of "Odd Thomas" is "A+".
The first sequel (the second book, "Forever Odd") was a disappointment after the first but that was to be expected. In my estimation, the author spent much more time on the first book than its sequel, likely because the sequel was pushed to market by his publisher (I may be completely wrong about that; I just present this "explanation" as one that fits my need to explain why this second book was so inferior to the first). Here's what's different: there is less story, less is at stake, there are more long, pointless passages that explain the details of a journey but which are not that interesting in themselves (e.g., the long slog through the underground waterway), there are less "supernatural" events, and less time is spent with or in developing the other characters. Yes, Odd does prevail at the end but this reader was left with the hope that the third installment (which I had already purchased) would be better (and it was). In comparison to the first book, the situations, the stakes, and the characters were rather poorly conceived. Notice that I just wrote "in comparison to the first book" because all by itself this second novel was pretty good; it just wasn't in the same league as the first. My rating here is a "B".
The third book, "Brother Odd," returns some of the glory of the first novel to its pages. The new characters are realized better and the situation is more interesting and more carefully explained than in the second book. Perhaps the author (or his editors) felt that more effort on the third would lead to a fourth (and perhaps that's what happened). There are more supernatural elements in this installment (a wise move by the author) and there is a better sense of risk (all the kids and the religious community) and the challenges to Odd are both more intricate and more interesting in comparison to those in "Forever Odd." However, the ultimate pay-off (i.e., the power behind the evil) is both too odd (forgive the pun) and too reminiscent of the classic sci-fi movie, "Forbidden Planet." When I finished reading this third book I thought, "Well, this one was better than the last but not nearly up to the first one." I wasn't worried by the switch from Elvis to Sinatra (I liked how Elvis' story was wrapped up) and I was touched by fact that the dog, Boo, was revealed as ghost (a small surprise in spite of the hint in the dog's name--Boo). I like the thought of dog-spirits helping our main man and, consequently, the thought that my lost canine companions might be close at hand when I need them to be near me. I even liked the final set-up leading to the next book (i.e., the hints that Odd would be drawn to the sea to solve some new mystery). All in all, my rating here is a "B+".
And now for the fourth book, "Odd Hours." <SPOILERS are ahead.> I have admitted to anticipating the book and buying it immediately when it was released. I even started reading it within an hour of buying it. But, by the time I was through the first third of the book I was becoming disappointed. By the time I was through two-thirds of the book I was sure about my feelings of disappointment. By the time I finished it, I was sort of in shock...here is probably the weakest shadow of the first novel yet. Here's what this story lacks: it lacks much sense of danger or mystery and it lacks any compelling new characters (the new ones are so vaguely drawn that I even briefly thought Mr. Koontz was trying to "tell me something" about the nature of good and evil by drawing his characters so flatly). I felt sort of cheated by the fact that the first third of the book is nothing but a romp through the underside of a pier while Odd tries to elude a big-man killer type (what's scary about that...knowing that Odd will prevail easily, even without the help of Boo?). The long sequence involving Odd's interrogation by the chief of police is interesting on one level but also weirdly vague and pointless. Is the chief possessed or what? And what is the meaning of the coyotes? What purpose, besides being just a set-up for a fifth book--because she is not in any way related to this story--does the Annmarie character serve and what is that odd promise of Odd's to die for her? I suppose that Koontz is trying to leap-frog this current installment by introducing a key character to a fifth novel. If so, I have to admit here that one thing I really despise about Hollywood's current trend in movie making is that that no new ideas are sought, only old ones that can lead to sequels that hopefully can ring more money out of the old idea at the expense of integral individual stories. [I track this trend back to the success of "The Lord of the Rings" movie trilogy. I will point out that by the end of three Christmas seasons the world was immersed in the multi-phased story spread out over years. However, the fact is, all three movies were originally filmed at once because it was assumed that the failure of the first would mean there'd be no money to produce the other two and thus the whole story could not be told. But, the "Ring" novels were all one long story from the very beginning, not a series of sequels to an original story.] My point here is that Koontz litters his books with not-at-all-veiled references to things in modern culture that he regards with some distain (and usually I agree with his estimations). In this fourth "Odd" book, I felt more than a bit used by the author in the sense that he had succumbed to pressure to make his book a "stepping stone" to another story, not a great story in and of itself (like the first one was). I suppose it is inevitable that there would be some commercial influence going on here, and very likely there is an "Odd" movie in the works (a "graphic novel"--a cartoon book or movie storyboard--is actually being published next month). OK. End of my rambling. My generous rating of this one, a "C+".
If there's anyone who's still reading this review, please hear this: I like "Odd Thomas" and I like the fact that his stories are going on, that he's not a one- or a two-hit-wonder. But, I would also appreciate the author more if he'd put some more care into future installments. He might just learn a thing or two by re-reading his first "Odd" adventure.
Please leave me a comment here if you liked, or didn't like, this review. Thanks!
Book Review: Disappointing the entire way through
Summary: 1 Stars
I have been such a huge Dean Koontz fan throughout the years and this has to be hands down the worse Odd Thomas book so far, the reading was tedious and not enjoyable the story lagged on and when usually he catches my attention and I'm reading the entire night through I had to force myself to finish this book. I thought surely the ending would make up for the lack of storyline but I was wrongBook Review: Don't read this unless you've read the earlier Odd novels!
Summary: 5 Stars
Well, okay, you'll no doubt enjoy this one on it's own, even if you haven't read the other novels about Odd. But really, you'll enjoy this one much more if you have started off with the first one.
For those familiar with Odd the fry cook, this is one more book to savor. Yes, it's a fun read, and yes, Koontz stands alone in his ability to match quirky situations, humor, terror, and lovable characters. It's the strangest blend, and only Koontz can carry it off.
Just buy and enjoy!
Book Review: Enjoyable episode in Odd's life that left some stones unturned
Summary: 4 Stars
Odd Hours is a relatively brief, flashing episode of Odd's life. If Odd's story were a weekly television drama, this would have been an adequate episode that began assuming viewers were familiar with the character and story, and it ends with the assumption that more will be explained and continued next week.
Odd Hours begins with Odd in a new town, Magic Beach, working for an eccentric aged Hollywood actor. Odd follows his intuition and psychic magnetism where it leads him. He finds himself burdened with preventing a nuclear attack on US soil, but this is no Vince Flynn novel. Odd employs his usual tactics of relying on his gifts and humble ways to foil the plans. In the process, he meets some interesting friends who aid him in the rescue.
In his conflicts with the bad guys, Odd is courageous and witty while doing what needs to be done. His "dead" companions are Frank Sinatra and a dog named Boo. Sinatra fills the role in the novel previously played by Elvis.
Koontz once again shines a light on the evil and destructive natures and impulses present in humanity. He also shows his higher regard for the goodness and gifts of people to overcome evil.
I think this is a good and entertaining follow-up to "Brother Odd" that Koontz fans will definitely want to read and will appreciate it. It loses a star for not offering more background on a key character and her circumstances. Perhaps this is left for the next book.