The Brain That Changes Itself: Stories of Personal Triumph from the Frontiers of Brain Science (James H. Silberman Books) by Norman Doidge Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $8.93 You Save: $7.07 (44%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $6.99 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of The Brain That Changes Itself: Stories of Personal Triumph from the Frontiers of Brain Science (James H. Silberman Books)
Book Review: worth reading, with caveats
Summary: 3 Stars
I have a general professional interest in psychology and brain science, which often leads me to be frustrated by the tendency towards reductionism and exaggeration. This book looked promising to me because the author is advertised as a psychoanalyst--something that usually does not mesh well with neuroscience. I was intrigued to see how Freud might think about modern psychology's biological determinism. On that score, I found The Brain That Changes Itself reasonably satisfying; the chapter on how neural plasticity can help us understand the impact of psychotherapy was among the best in the book. I very much appreciate the emphasis on how experience (including talk therapy) and culture, not just genes and drugs, shape the brain. That is something that is easy to miss in viewing the pretty brain scans of contemporary popular science. I also found the appendix on how culture works through neural plasticity interesting, although I don't find it helpful to define culture as Doidge seems to--something akin to cultivation and taste (a definition that leads to a problematic hierarchy of cultures based on somewhat arbitrary criteria). It is, however, important to recognize that culture and the brain have a reciprocal relationship.
My main concern with the book is that much of the argument seems to imply that the brain is infinitely malleable with the right exercises and effort. Though Doidge does note at points that plasticity is not infinite, he also seems to endorse the very American cultural script that individuals have total control over everything that happens to them. If babies are properly stimulated they will all be geniuses! If ADHD children go through the proper attentional exercises they will suddenly excel! If the elderly go to brain gyms they will never lose their memory! These, unfortunately, are primarily openings for marketers rather than scientific realities. Of course we have some control, and the key findings of neural plasticity research have been helpful in supporting that, but there are some things that are not just about effort--but also about care and community. Overall, I did find this book interesting and worth reading, but also found myself worried about what seemed to me strategic exaggeration.
Book Review: A fascinating book
Summary: 5 Stars
This book gives new hope to many people who would be left to face a very limited life. Well written and accessible to non-professionals.Book Review: Perfect for the layman
Summary: 4 Stars
I ordered this book on recommendation from a friend because I suffer from brain damage due to a stroke. Not only has the information made me hopeful about a possible resolution for my problems, it would be fascinating for anyone who has an interest in science and anatomy. The medical world is still in its infancy as far as understanding the way the brain works. This author uses anecdotes to convey complex concepts which makes the information accessible to the layman.Book Review: Disappointed with the audio
Summary: 2 Stars
If you have a choice of book or audio, book might hold your attention, although it was a bit too anecdotal for me. Heavy on the personal histories, light on the science behind the miracles.
PN
Book Review: One of the best books I have ever read.
Summary: 5 Stars
On the first audio disk of this series (I bought the audiobook)
there is a story about a woman whose vestibular apparatus in her
inner ear was destroyed by a destructive antibiotic. The woman
could not even stand up she was so affected by not having any
sense of balance. With a very simple (conceptually anyway)
electronic device that fed back accelerometer signals to an
area on her tongue she was able, not only to link her brain
into this machine outside her body speaking in mechanical
codes to her own brain, but eventually the feedback allowed
her inner neurons to silence the noise she was hearing inside
and cure herself altogether. She no longer needs the external
device.
This is just one of the many different examples in different
dimensions that illuminates many newly discovered aspects of the
human brain. This book is full of them. Not only that but reading
between the lines gives one many ideas of how this kind of information
will change the world and an idea of the magnitude of the tragedy
that has been caused by human ignorance and dogma about the brain.
This story is one of many that completely turns around the ideas
most of the world has had for centuries about the nature of the
human being. In my mind that makes this book one of the most
important and most eye opening books I have ever or will ever
read.
This book ought to be required reading for every human being,
because it is only in redefining what we are for ourselves
that the human mental world will change for the better to enable
us to meet the challenges of the future for all life on planet
Earth.
Bravo ... 5/5 stars!!!