The Lost Warrior (Warriors) by Erin Hunter, Dan Jolley Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $2.32 You Save: $4.67 (67%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $1.40 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of The Lost Warrior (Warriors)
Book Review: The Lost Warrior: Graystripe In Twolegplace
Summary: 4 Stars
As anyone who's read Dawn knows, Graystripe was captured by Twolegs when rescuing cats from their traps. This manga follows his adventure in Twolegplace and his desperate attempts to escape...and what happens when he meets Millie, a kittypet in the same Twolegplace.
The Lost Warrior is good...just not spectacular. They could have made the story a lot longer and made a better, more detailed manga.
Now for the storyline. It's good. But... a little boring. And short. Graystripe wants to get out of Twolegplace but seems to have given up hope. He's seemingly lost all his warrior instincts, and after (spoilers begin here) losing a fight with a kittypet, Graystripe begins to believe he'll never get out of there.
Then he meets Millie, another kittypet. Fascinated by the forest life, she wants to be taught how to fight and hunt, and Graystripe meets her demands. Slowly, his warrior instincts begin to return, though Graystripe still has little hope. Eventually Silverstream convinces Graystripe to look for the Clans, and he goes, though he meets obstacles along the way. (spoilers end here)
So it's good. But not totally awesome, and the plot could have been expanded a lot more. I HAVE flipped through it again and still enjoyed it, but don't expect the most amazing book in the world...it pales much in comparison to the regular Warriors.
So this book is worth buying, just don't walk into the bookstore expecting the best manga there is to read. If you do, you may be a bit disappointed.
Book Review: bought this for a niece...
Summary: 5 Stars
I bought this for a niece ( 9yrs ) and she loved it, of course she had already read every other book in this series and loved all of those as well.Book Review: Immediate Turnoff
Summary: 2 Stars
I found out about this book a few months from the release and was really excited ... until I saw it. I flipped through it, remarked at how lazy the artist was, being a comic artist myself. This is work that is done to just pop it out like an amatuer does, NOT a paid professional. It was clearly done to make a few more dollars at the lowest expense. The cats all pretty much look the SAME and it was too short.
It could have been in a much better way.
Book Review: Awesome story! But much, much, much too short!
Summary: 4 Stars
I think that the Lost Warrior was really great, but it was way too short and I finished it in just half an hour. I also don't understand why it says "to be continued" at the end. Overall, I think this was a really, really great story...especially for Manga.Book Review: The Lost Warrior: Graystripe
Summary: 3 Stars
I don't like this book, really. They could've made it better but they didn't. I finished it in less than 15 minutes. This book is in manga style and I think the drawings are off. What's with Feathertail with the fluffy thing on her head. Feathertail does not look like that. Also, if you put this book into a real story, it would probably be only like 3 chapters long. The plot isn't that big. I expected something better, with more answers to questions. You don't need to buy this book. YOu can just go the library or the bookstore and read it there and I bet you won't want to read it ever again. Well that's how I felt.
I'd give this book C average.