The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals by Richard Plant Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $7.97 You Save: $10.02 (56%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $0.71 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals
Book Review: So-so analysis
Summary: 3 Stars
I thought this book was good, however it lacked focus. It's difficult to be critical of a book in a field of study with so little additional research. It's one of a handful of other texts on the issue of gay persecution during the holocaust.
Plant's personal relation to the gay persecution certainly makes thebook emotional at times (and often hard to stomach). However, as I say, the book lacked focus. It discussed variosu circumstances and people surrounding the holocaust, but failed to make an attempt at why -- why were homosexuals, singledout along with the jews, communists, gypsies, ect...
Gunter Grau's "Hidden Holocaust" which is a collection of primary documents does take a stab at this question. SInce its not a narrative like Plant's book its tougher to sit and read, however, it was much more concise and structed.
Book Review: The Ignored Nazi Genocide
Summary: 4 Stars
Until fairly recently, the homosexual men who suffered under the National Socialist regime have been ignored as a victim group. Part of the reason for this is obviously due to the suffering of the Jewish people, the scale of which dwarfed other targets of Nazi hatred. But it must also be viewed as the result of an odious attitude prevailing after the war that while the persecution of Jews, gypsies and other groups may have been appalling, the homosexuals pretty much deserved it. Due to the perceived taboo nature into the subject, research into the suffering of this group only began to emerge with increasingly liberal attitudes towards homosexuality and support for the gay rights movement. Richard Plant was one of the first scholars to seriously investigate the Nazi campaign against homosexuals, and set the standard for others to follow with the publication of `The Pink Triangle'. Drawing on his experience as a gay German refugee, he details the appalling brutality that was afflicted on those suspected of homosexuality, and describes the sadistic ruthlessness employed in seeking to hunt out gay men.
Aside from the sheer magnitude of the Nazi persecution of homosexuals, what makes Germany interesting is that homosexuality was relatively tolerated in advanced urban areas. Gay bars existed, and attempts to legalise homosexuality were seriously fought by respected politicians. The Nazi Party was certainly not immune to this relaxed attitude, as Plant describes on a chapter of the openly gay Ernst Roehm, chief of the extremely homoerotic SA. While I feel Plant over-emphasises the tolerant nature of pre-Nazi urban Germany, he does point out that such sentiments did not extend across the whole nation. Far from it. The desire to root out homosexuals was one of many obsessions in the bizarre mind of Hedrick Himmler, and such sentiments were to be echoed by the majority of the nation. A chapter is devoted to Himmler's insistence that homosexuals were an unnatural breed, and constantly posing a threat to the soul and future of the Aryan people. Unlike the Jews, homosexuals were still considered to be Aryans, albeit extremely defective. Thus, whilst saved from the fate of the gas chamber, they were nonetheless viewed as the lowest of the low in terms of non-Jewish prisoners. Marked out by a distinctive pink triangle, they were routinely given the most strenuous and hazardous jobs in an attempt to `straighten them out'. Few made it to see the liberation of the camps. Those that did survive the back-breaking labour, disease, beatings, pseudo-medical experiments, forced castration and an endless of list of other unfathomable cruelty often found themselves locked up by unsympathetic liberators, inclined to view the infamous Paragraph 175 as being legitimate.
While much has been written on the nature of Germany's concentration camps, Plant gives us a unique insight into the suffering of the gay men who died within their fences. Unfortunately, such suffering has not been consigned to history. Hatred of homosexuals still exists within Western society. And the shocking behaviour of the Nazis continues within the law in backward states across the globe. Many feel that no lessons should be learned from the Nazi war against homosexuals. The reader of `The Pink Triangle' will hopefully disagree.
Book Review: The silent holocaust
Summary: 4 Stars
This work is a great eye opener for those wishing to discover much of what I have come to call the 'silent holocaust'. The treatment of homosexuals by the Nazi army was harsh and cruel yet the names of the dead resound silent throughout much of history. Through this silence we can see how our society has not changed in it's compassion and cultural 'taboos' even when bigotry reaches into mass-killing of innocent peoples. Today the murder of innocent men and women for their sexuality continues as the mentality of ethnic (and thus "moral") superiority.This book should be read by anyone who desires to learn about this 'silent holocaust' and how to prevent history for repeating itself.
Namaste and Peace to all!
More The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals reviews:
1 2
1 2