The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference by Malcolm Gladwell Summary and Reviews
|
List Price: Our Price: $3.99 You Save: $11.00 (73%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $3.50 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference
Book Review: The book that tipped
Summary: 4 Stars
In the Tipping Point Malcolm Gladwell provides an overview on the phenomenon of social epidemics, the underlying reasons that make things tip. The book is well researched with academic contributions entangled with interesting narrative that illustrates the theory. I would have rated the book five stars if not for two issues. Firstly, the book is almost totally lacks critique about the theories and examples presented. Secondly, while the book contains a lot of interesting ideas, the effort to synthesize them is half-hearted. Mr. Gladwell has a made a great effort in going through a vast literature ? mainly academic, but also popular ? to find a number of key factors behind the social epidemics and some interesting narrative to illustrate them. However, the book is not at all academic, rather the value of Mr. Gladwell?s writing comes from packaging academic research to simple concepts and explaining these in length through examples. For those interested in details, there are some ten pages of endnotes that explain the concepts more thoroughly and provide references to the original literature.
So what makes things tip? According to Mr. Gladwell this can be divided into three explaining categories: (1) the law of the few, (2) the stickiness factor, and (3) the power of context. The law of the few states that only a very small part of people are behind the word-of-mouth epidemics and they can be categorized into connectors, mavens, and salesmen. Connectors are persons with exceptionally large personal networks, mavens are experts on the ?right? market price and on spotting bargains, and salesmen are persons with extraordinary skill to persuade. Stickiness factor refers to small ?sticky? details that can greatly boost for instance the effect of advertising campaigns. Finally, the power of context states that people are powerfully affected by the surrounding circumstances in making their decisions.
The Tipping Point provides a way of interpreting what factors have contributed to a certain epidemic or trend. I would have appreciated an effort to synthesize the theory and preferably in a more normative manner, e.g. by providing a framework on how, say, advertising campaigns can be made more effective from the epidemics point of view. Now the focus is on providing somewhat miscellaneous ideas that often are unintuitive, but which have at least some evidence to support them. There would have been a more objective flavor to the book if Mr. Gladwell would have also discussed the limitations of the theory and other explaining factors. For instance, a product might be popular simply because it is superb without particular need of endorsement from connectors, mavens and salesmen; crime in New York might have dropped due to other factors than ?power of context? in form of e.g. removing graffiti from the underground (such as the legalization of abortion as suggested in the Freakonomics book). Nevertheless, the Tipping Point is a thought-provoking and interesting book worth reading.
Book Review: What's all the fuss about?
Summary: 2 Stars
There's not a lot of substance to this theory and certainly nothing much that's new. It's by no means clear how the examples are supposed to prove the theory and there is certainly nothing to help one cause, predict or frankly even recognise a 'tipping point'.However, notwithstanding that I do predict that the publication of this book will be a tipping point in the use of the word 'maven'.
Book Review: A rattling good and informative read!
Summary: 5 Stars
I found the material very useful and entertaingly written, and can well understand why it has shot up the best-seller lists. I can apply & use quite a bit of this, both in my own business and in my personal life.Book Review: Entertaining read for an intercontinental flight
Summary: 4 Stars
This is a well-written and entertaining book. From a wealth of empirical and anecdotal evidence, Gladwell develops a sort of a theory how social phenomena can suddenly start spreading rapidly. He draws an analogy with epidemics, and he bases his thoughts on a few simple laws"; key to this is his finding that small things will eventually make the big difference. Not all the examples Gladwell quotes are entirely convincing, and some of the cause-effect relationships he establishes are a bit of an intellectual stretch. Moreover, his book - without saying so - once again highlights that social science theories can only explain with hindsight - and ever that never conclusively - , and that its laws" do not have the same predictive power as the laws of natural sciences. One last point: I wonder whether Gladwell's theory applies to the same extent when it comes to other cultural settings than America's. After all, this is a very American book (as a non-American born and raised in Continental Europe, I still cannot relate to Hush Puppies and understand the fuzz about them!). Patterns of social interactions - which are at the core of Gladwell's theory - depend on the broader cultural context and their concept of interpersonal relationships; this is not the same everywhere. Still, Gladwell's Tipping Point" is a worthwhile read (e.g., on a long-haul flight) and thus highly recommendable. Book Review: Fascinating yet simple and entertaining
Summary: 5 Stars
This book gives a fascinating account of how mass movements and social trends develop and spread so explosively in so little time. Far from being a dry, jargon packed sociology book, this is written in a flowing and down to earth writing style that is very appealing. The writer goes into detail about how different types of people, message and environment interact to either make or a break an "epidemic", be it drug use or fashion trends. One of the most useful features of the book is how the author repeatedly reminds us where we are up to in this analysis, so we never forget what important points that have been raised in previous chapters are relevant to the current one. The author manages to do this in such a way as to never seem patronising, which there is always the potential for with this kind of approach. Another excellent feature is how after every principle is introduced, a famous real life example is given, so we can instantly match the abstract concept to real life. This really helps his analysis come to life, and ensures we fully understand the points raised.
One minor weakness of the book is the authors long description of his personal acquaintances whom he feels exemplify the themes he discusses. unlike the historical real life examples he gives, it is hard for us to see his point when applied to people we do not know and will never meet. This is however only a minor weakness, and is made up for by his use of real life famous historical examples as well. The book is a very pleasant read, and deservedly gets full marks.