The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland Summary and Reviews

The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland
by Lewis Carroll, L. Frank Baum

The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland
Our Price: $65.00
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy Used: from $57.74 (click here)
Category: Book
See more book details and other editions


or

Book Summary Information

Author: L. Frank Baum, Lewis Carroll
Illustrator: Lisbeth Zwerger
Edition: Hardcover
Audio: English (Original Language); English (Unknown); English (Published)
Format: Box set, Illustrated
Published: 2001-09
ISBN: 0735813426
Number of pages: 216
Reading Level: Ages 4-8
Publisher: North-South Books

Book Reviews of The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland

Book Review: artistic license or mere sloppiness?
Summary: 3 Stars

I really wanted to like this boxed edition of Alice In Wonderland and Wizard of Oz, as I happen to admire Lisbeth Zwerger's art. Unfortunately, there were glaring inconsistencies between the illustrations and the text which marred any appreciation I could have had. I'll just give one--the first I noticed when I opened _Alice In Wonderland_.

In the scene where Alice encounters the rather severe and pedantic caterpillar, Zwerger adopts what I consider an inappropriate top-down perspective, reducing the caterpillar to a small, weak creature and completely ignoring the fact that Alice is the same size as the caterpillar and viewing him from a lower position (he sits on a mushroom, thereby gaining height over Alice). The text specifies that Alice has to stand on tiptoe to see what is on top of the mushroom. I have always thought that young readers (as well as old) are meant to identify with Alice and see things from her perspective. Instead, we tower over the caterpillar, taking away the unusual perspective that Dodgson would have wished us to have. Tenniel's illustration is faithful to the the text and the child's perpsective--which Zwerger's is not.

What is more, with Zwerger's perspective, it is difficult to imagine the caterpillar as a stern, brusque, off-putting character-- much like some adults who have little tolerance for children("Who are _you_?";or "What do you mean by that?" said the caterpillar sternly "Explain yourself.") The text mentions, among other things, that Alice is rather shy of him. From Alice's (and thus the reader's) perpective, the caterpillar is an intimidating figure. Not so in Zwerger's interpretation, where the caterpillar is not only diminutive, but nervous, self-conscious-looking thing, puffing on a cigarette.

Which brings me to the most glaring and incomprehensible departure from the text: the cigarette. The story clearly indicates that the caterpillar is smoking a hookah. Zwerger perversely ignores the details of the story and substitutes hookah for ciggy. Is this artistic license, or sloppiness? Either way, a child reading "hookah" for the first time will be betrayed by Zwerger's illustration; older readers who like to think the artist should be faithful to the text will find the changes annoying.

Together, these inconsistencies dampen the pleasure I might have gained from Zwerger's lovely pictures and Carroll's story.

And this was just one picture, from the Alice book only; there are a few other mismatches and inconsistencies running through the book. I haven't yet looked at those of Oz, but I am too disappointed with the first to try.

For the meanwhile, the books remain in their slipcase, in a remote part of the bookshelf, while I enjoy the original and delightful illustrations by Tenniel.

Children's Books

Book Subjects
Most talked about in Oz: Under the Rainbow
The Wizard of Oz: Movie Storybook ImageThe Wizard of Oz: Movie Storybook
by Gail Herman
Scholastic; Published: 1998-12; Paperback; Book
Best price: $82.99
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Oxford World's Classics) ImageThe Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Oxford World's Classics)
by L. Frank Baum
Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 2000-03-30; Paperback; Book
Best price: $1.48
Price in other shops: $13.95
The Emerald City of Oz (Books of Wonder) ImageThe Emerald City of Oz (Books of Wonder)
by L. Frank Baum
HarperCollins; Published: 1993-04-23; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $9.95
Price in other shops: $25.99
The Magic of Oz (Books of Wonder) ImageThe Magic of Oz (Books of Wonder)
by L. Frank Baum
HarperCollins; Published: 1999-09-29; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $15.38
Price in other shops: $25.99
The Zen of Oz: Ten Spiritual Lessons from Over the Rainbow ImageThe Zen of Oz: Ten Spiritual Lessons from Over the Rainbow
by Joey Green
Renaissance Books; Published: 1998-10-19; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $46.99
Glinda of Oz (Oz, 14) ImageGlinda of Oz (Oz, 14)
by L. Frank Baum
HarperCollins; Published: 2000-05-31; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $15.48
Price in other shops: $25.99
Golden Wizdom Beyond The Emerald City ImageGolden Wizdom Beyond The Emerald City
by Ilene Kimsey
Toto-Ly Ozsome Pub; Published: 2000-07-19; Paperback; Book
Best price: $5.80
Price in other shops: $21.95
The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland ImageThe Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland
by Lewis Carroll, L. Frank Baum
North-South Books; Published: 2001-09; Hardcover; Book
Price in other shops: $29.95
Cooking in Oz: Kitchen Wizardry and a Century of Marvels from America's Favorite Tale ImageCooking in Oz: Kitchen Wizardry and a Century of Marvels from America's Favorite Tale
by Elaine Willingham, Stephen Cox, Tina Cassimatis, Blanche Cox
Cumberland House Publishing; Published: 1999-11-01; Paperback; Book
Best price: $14.95
Price in other shops: $16.95
The Annotated Wizard of Oz  (Centennial Edition) ImageThe Annotated Wizard of Oz (Centennial Edition)
by L. Frank Baum
W.W. Norton & Co.; Published: 2000-09-17; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $23.00
Price in other shops: $39.95